The politics of malls

Republican Columbus mayoral candidate Bill Todd has slammed incumbent Democratic Mayor Mike Coleman over the lawsuit the city filed against TL-Columbus Associates, the current owner of downtown’s City Center mall:

The only thing Mike Coleman accomplished with this political stunt is to make Columbus look unprofessional and anti-business. That is precisely the opposite message the Mayor should be sending to mall developers, investors, retailers, and other serious professionals who might be able to help us find a solution to City Center’s troubles – something Mike Coleman failed to do during his eight year snooze in City Hall.

But as Buckeye State Blog observes, one of Todd’s ideas was a Keloesque move for the city to take over the mall using eminent domain:

So, let’s get this straight, when a Democratic elected official decides to replace an absentee landlord of a major commerical property project by going to court and declaring that landlord in default so the city can replace the landlord with new developers, that’s heavy-handed, and anti-business. But when a Republican candidate, on the same issue, proposes a more radical plan and instead have the government seize that property by eminent domain… that’s neither heavy-handed or anti-business?

I fail to see much of a difference between the two. Actually, Coleman’s plan is more acceptable since the city is alleging breach of contract- the non-payment of rent- which is fair game. Though I can’t help thinking that there’s more to this story than we’re getting.

I criticized Todd for his land-grab idea back when he first talked about it in May. (Just for those who think I never say anything bad about Republicans.)

The bigger picture here is that Capitol South, which owns the land under City Center and is a private non-profit that acts sort of like the city’s land ownership company, made a mistake when they gave a 90-year lease to TL-Columbus and they’re looking to undo it. TL-Columbus hasn’t done a good job with the mall, but it’s not exactly their fault that enclosed malls are a dying breed, or that downtown malls are a dubious propositon anyway.

Here’s a radical idea: sell the mall and the land to an actual for-profit company and keep government hands out of it.

3 comments on “The politics of malls”

  1. Posted by Modern Esquire | Aug 6, 2007 3:33 pm

    I don’t know what the “solution” is for the City Center. I just thought it was shocking that of all the criticisms Todd decided to do about Coleman’s actions, he went with the radical, anti-business approach given his recent even more radical statements.

    I’d say management of the mall is one piece of the puzzle. Another is the fact that mall shopping has largely been replaced with internet shopping. The other is the location. As Columbus has grown out with additional exurb shopping centers, the City Center has lost a demographic.

    If you look at it’s present location compared to urban residential development, the City Center is not ideally located. Most of the new condos and developments in the City have been closer to the river or in the Arena District (far too far for urban residents to be expected to shop.) I think the closest residential development is the new condos being built on Capitol Square near the Rhodes office building. That may drive the demand for urban shopping up some. But the fact is that malls have been dying out since the 90s. Perhaps if it had a movie theater or some night clubs and catered to the late night urban crowd it could be revitalized. But it’s been years since I’ve lived in Columbus, so who knows?

  2. Posted by R. Lee Ermey | Aug 6, 2007 7:12 pm

    good point. i think them should do a combo of retail and living space. here is an idea, how about actually making affordable lofts for young professionals? these condos that are 700 sq ft and $160k is ridiculous. City center would be perfect for 1200 sq ft apartments/lofts for $130k. that would attract YPs.

  3. Posted by Eric | Aug 7, 2007 7:58 pm

    Esquire - Just like you can’t expect a couple of Dominion Home developments to support Polaris, you can’t expect a couple thousand downtown residents to singlehandedly support City Center.

    R. Lee - 1,200 sqft for $130,000 doesn’t add up and would amount to developers selling at a loss. This is capitalism, premium land goes for premium dollars. “Affordable Downtown Housing” is something of an oxymoron. Remember the three rules of real estate…location, location, and location.

    Look around at other cities and you’ll quickly realize that 700 sqft for $160k is a bargain.

Leave a comment

The Feed

1 In 7 Kitchens Would Fail Food Safety Inspection, Study Finds

Could your kitchen at home pass a restaurant inspection? New research suggests that at least one in seven home kitchens would flunk the kind of....

nbc4i.com

Sep 3, 2010 1:09 pm

Store Owner Pelts Robber With Pepsi Cans

A Texas store owner took on a gunman using an unusual weapon: soda cans.

nbc4i.com

Sep 3, 2010 1:06 pm

Filthy: Office Fridges Often Dirtier Than Restrooms

A recent survey by the American Dietetic Association finds that they can be a breeding ground for germs.

nbc4i.com

Sep 3, 2010 1:02 pm

Man Stuck In Hot Tub Calls 911

911 dispatchers received an unusual call for help when a man says he becomes trapped inside a hot tub.

nbc4i.com

Sep 3, 2010 12:48 pm

OVI Checkpoint In Licking County

Central Ohio Law Enforcement agencies are teaming up to catch drunk drivers this Labor Day weekend.

nbc4i.com

Sep 3, 2010 12:47 pm

Pregnant Amish Woman Critical After Buggy Crash

Authorities say the driver of a sport-utility vehicle rear-ended a buggy in northeast Ohio, injuring an Amish woman who was eight months pregnant,....

nbc4i.com

Sep 3, 2010 12:16 pm

All Good? Bank Robber Returns Money, Still Arrested

A man robs a bank in Charlotte, N.C., then decides to return the money during his "getaway."

nbc4i.com

Sep 3, 2010 11:58 am

Gahanna Couple Faces Federal Fraud Charges

A federal grand jury has charged a Gahanna couple in a 47 count indictment alleging that they defrauded more than fifty victims out of more....

nbc4i.com

Sep 3, 2010 11:37 am

Store Owner Fights Robber With Soda Cans

A Texas store owner took on a gunman using an unusual weapon: soda cans.

nbc4i.com

Sep 3, 2010 11:32 am

Office Refrigerators Breeding Ground For Germs

A recent survey by the American Dietetic Association finds that they can be a breeding ground for germs.

nbc4i.com

Sep 3, 2010 11:28 am

US Airways ekes out August traffic gain

US Airways Group Inc. finished the last month of the summer vacation season with a meager increase in passenger traffic, though a key revenue measure....

Business First of Columbus

Sep 3, 2010 11:13 am

Husted reports another big fundraising month

The campaign of Republican secretary of state candidate Jon Husted continues to build a healthy warchest....

The Daily Briefing

Sep 3, 2010 10:39 am

Threats Diminish For Ohio Mussels And Mollusks.

Conservationists and government wildlife agencies are working to restore small but important creatures to the state's rivers and streams. Mussels....

WOSU

Sep 3, 2010 10:22 am

Coroner: Baby Died After Body Flushed With Alcohol

An Ohio coroner says a 7-month-old Indiana baby died after his body was flushed with alcohol and not a saline solution during heart surgery at a....

nbc4i.com

Sep 3, 2010 10:12 am

Nationwide to sponsor the Memorial

Nationwide Mutual Insurance Co. is stepping into the big leagues of professional golf by becoming presenting sponsor of the Memorial Tournament in....

Business First of Columbus

Sep 3, 2010 9:58 am

TGIF!!

GO BUCKEYES!  We were at the game last night in Ohio Stadium and it was very hot!  It was a terrific game with lots of excitement and....

Ohio 15th District

Sep 3, 2010 9:56 am

How Not To Give An Opening Statement

As Ohio’s debates draw near, I’d like to share an example with all candidates of how not to give an opening statement. This cringe inducing....

Buckeye State Blog

Sep 3, 2010 9:42 am

Oars Stolen From Youngest Atlantic Rower

The Ohio woman who became the youngest person to row across the Atlantic alone says oars used in her feat have been lost in a vehicle theft.

nbc4i.com

Sep 3, 2010 9:33 am

U.S. unemployment up to 9.6%

The nation's jobless rate saw its first increase in four months during August, when U.S. employers cut their payrolls by 54,000 jobs, according to....

Business First of Columbus

Sep 3, 2010 9:32 am

Suit Challenges Ohio Absentee Ballot Methods

Four voters have filed a federal lawsuit challenging the different ways Ohio counties handle mailings of absentee ballot applications and the ballots....

nbc4i.com

Sep 3, 2010 9:31 am

Time Warner, ESPN parent reach deal

A standoff between Walt Disney Co. and Time Warner Cable Inc. as the two sides drew up new contract terms ended late Thursday. (DIS) (TWC)

Business First of Columbus

Sep 3, 2010 9:12 am

DGA Takes On Fox News Over Kasich

The Democratic Governors Association has declared war on Fox News, and John Kasich is right in the middle of it. The DGA has filed a complaint....

Buckeye State Blog

Sep 3, 2010 9:07 am

All Good? Bank Robber Returns Money, Still Arrested

A man robs a bank in Charlotte, N.C., then decides to return the money during his "getaway."

nbc4i.com

Sep 3, 2010 8:53 am

Week 2: Football Friday Nite

For Week 2, the FFN is teaming is planning to cover 15 games, including a tailgate at the Olentangy Orange at Olentangy Liberty.

nbc4i.com

Sep 3, 2010 8:41 am

Pregnant Amish Woman Hurt In Buggy Crash

Authorities say the driver of a sport-utility vehicle rear-ended a buggy in northeast Ohio, injuring an Amish woman who was eight months pregnant,....

nbc4i.com

Sep 3, 2010 8:25 am

Fans Celebrate Arrival Of Buckeye Football Season

Ever since kick off at the Ohio State and Marshall game Thursday evening, excitement has been in the air around Ohio Stadium. It screams one thing -....

nbc4i.com

Sep 3, 2010 8:16 am

Obama Plans Trip To Cleveland Next Wednesday

President Barack Obama is planning another trip to Ohio in this midterm election year, this time taking him to Cleveland.

nbc4i.com

Sep 3, 2010 7:37 am

Hot, Dry Summer Speeds Ohio Sweet Corn Season

This summer's weather has caused Ohio's crop of sweet corn to pop out faster than usual, and farm stands expect to run out of homegrown ears....

nbc4i.com

Sep 3, 2010 7:36 am

Bank Robber Robs Bank and then Returns Money

A man robs a bank in Charlotte then decides to return the money during his getaway.

nbc4i.com

Sep 3, 2010 7:17 am

Buckeyes Silence Thundering Herd, 45-7

Ohio State sent out a message to opponents and to the nation: They're not playing around.

nbc4i.com

Sep 3, 2010 7:09 am

Activists In Columbus Debate Federal Budget Policies

Conservative groups and liberal groups in Ohio are both trying to put the heat on Washington to approve policies they like. That was evident....

WOSU

Sep 3, 2010 6:47 am

Funk Band War Suing PepsiCo Over Song

Members of the original funk band War say they can't be friends with PepsiCo.

nbc4i.com

Sep 3, 2010 6:21 am

Add Hip-Hop To 'Rock Band' Thanks To Snoop Dogg

Rap and rock will collide once again - this time in a video game.

nbc4i.com

Sep 3, 2010 6:15 am

FBI: 6 Accused In Forced Labor Of 400 Thai Workers

Federal authorities are accusing six people of luring 400 laborers from Thailand to the United States and forcing them to work in what the FBI calls....

nbc4i.com

Sep 2, 2010 11:07 pm

Agencies Find No Link Between Rash, Newest Pampers

The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission and Health Canada say they haven't yet found a link between Pampers Dry Max diapers and some....

nbc4i.com

Sep 2, 2010 11:06 pm

Pregnant Amish Woman Is Hurt In Ohio Buggy Crash

Authorities say the driver of a sport-utility vehicle rear-ended a buggy in northeast Ohio, injuring an Amish woman who was eight months pregnant,....

nbc4i.com

Sep 2, 2010 11:03 pm

Buckeyes Silence Thundering Herd, 45-7

Ohio State sent out a message to opponents and to the nation:  they are not playing around.

nbc4i.com

Sep 2, 2010 10:51 pm

Buckeyes Silence Thundering Herd, 45-7

The Buckeyes made a statement in the season opener, topping Marshall 45-7.

nbc4i.com

Sep 2, 2010 10:31 pm

Buckeye Game Not Must See For Everyone

Some choose family and folk music over football

nbc4i.com

Sep 2, 2010 9:44 pm

Fans Celebrate Arrival Of Buckeyes Football Season

Ever since kick off at the Ohio State and Marshall game Thursday evening, excitement has been in the air around Ohio Stadium. It screams one thing -....

nbc4i.com

Sep 2, 2010 9:15 pm

Stimulus Money Trains Unemployed Ohioans For Logisitics Jobs

Ohio Impact: A program to train more than 1,000 unemployed Ohioans to work in the logistics field is underway in Columbus.

nbc4i.com

Sep 2, 2010 6:00 pm

Deadline Looms For Boy At Center Of Custody Battle

A legal and verbal battle has erupted over adoptive rights of a little boy and the clock is ticking.

nbc4i.com

Sep 2, 2010 5:42 pm

No Sign Of Oil Spill After Gulf Platform Fire

The Coast Guard is saying there are no immediate signs of a spill from an oil platform fire in the Gulf of Mexico off the Louisiana coast.

nbc4i.com

Sep 2, 2010 5:28 pm

Toxin Advisory Hurts Businesses Around Deer Creek Park

Mt. Sterling is the last town some drivers pass through on your way to Deer Creek State Park. But ever since the Ohio Department of Natural Resources....

nbc4i.com

Sep 2, 2010 5:22 pm

Coast Guard: No Oil Sheen From Gulf Explosion

An oil platform exploded and caught fire Thursday off the Louisiana coast, the second such disaster in the Gulf of Mexico in less than five months.....

nbc4i.com

Sep 2, 2010 5:08 pm

Hoarder Sent To Jail

Judge runs out of patience.

nbc4i.com

Sep 2, 2010 5:07 pm

Gov. Strickland Commutes Ohio Inmate's Death Sentence

UPDATE: Ohio Gov. Ted Strickland has commuted the death sentence of an inmate who claims innocence in a triple slaying.

nbc4i.com

Sep 2, 2010 5:00 pm

Obama in Ohio again next week

President Barack Obama is touching back down in Ohio again next week with a visit to Cleveland on Wednesday, the White House confirmed this....

The Daily Briefing

Sep 2, 2010 4:12 pm

Buckeye Forum: Election season

Dispatch political affairs reporters Alan Johnson, JIm Siegel and Mark Niquette talk about the candidates in the upcoming election....

The Daily Briefing

Sep 2, 2010 3:58 pm

Football Buckeyes Can't Afford To Look Past Herd

UPDATE: More than 105,000 are expected at Ohio Stadium for Ohio State's 121st season-opening game.

nbc4i.com

Sep 2, 2010 3:53 pm